Sarah and Peach meet at a party and bond over their love for Alien (1979) and Sigourney Weaver. As a result, their mutual interest sparks Sarah's curiosity about Peach's sexuality. To shed light on the mystery, Sarah and her housemate Jennifer turn to social media for clues, only to find it unreliable. As she invites Peach over for a promising film night, Sarah's self-doubt skyrockets, and a simple but crucial question emerges: What if Sarah just asked?