X

Join or Sign In

Sign in to customize your TV listings

Continue with Facebook Continue with email

By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

Finding Mr. Christmas

10 men compete in a series of festive challenges that will showcase their acting chops and their holiday spirit. Jonathan Bennett hosts while these lovable guys vie to become the next Hallmark leading man.

Loading. Please wait...

Content not available in your region? ExpressVPN can help you stay connected wherever you are. Get 4 extra months FREE with TV Guide's exclusive offer.

Cast & Crew See All

Jonathan Bennett
Self - Host
Melissa Peterman
Self - Judge
Craig Geoghan
Self - Contestant

Season 2 Episode Guide See All

Episode 1

The Search for Mr. Christmas

Mon, Oct 27, 202542 mins

The ten guys vying to be the second Mr. Christmas, who will be the lead in a Hallmark holiday movie, arrive at the house, meet the other nine, and introduce themselves to the viewing audience. The acting experience of the ten ranges from one who has a over a decade of acting work in minor roles, to a few who have no acting experience whatsoever. For the Festive Faceoff, Jonathan and Melissa want to see their personality shine in they being asked to personalize a Santa outfit which they will unveil, acting personality and all, in front of the judges and the other contestants. The winner of the Festive Faceoff will get an advantage leading into the Star Quality Challenge, which they, in pairs, will act with Hallmark star, guest judge Janel Parrish, in a traditional meet cute, the two contestants who are somewhat adversaries in getting Janel's character's attention. The added twist is that they only have one take, they needing to go with the flow if anything goes awry, which if it does happen will probably be related to them needing to ski at the same time, some who have never skied in their lives.

Where to Watch
Finding Mr. Christmas, Season 2 Episode 1 image

Featured Video

Finding Mr. Christmas: Season 2
Finding Mr. Christmas: Season 2
0:32

0:32 Finding Mr. Christmas: Season 2

Awards

  • 2026 - GLAAD Media Award - Outstanding Reality Competition Program - nominated

Popular Shows See all shows

Gold Rush

16 Seasons
A reality TV show that follows crews mining the gold placer deposits of the Yukon Territory.
58   Metascore
2010 Reality

The Curse of Oak Island

13 Seasons
Rick and Marty Lagina, two brothers from Michigan with a life-long interest in the mystery of Oak Island, renew efforts to discover the legendary treasure with sophisticated machinery.
2014 Documentary, Reality

The Voice

29 Seasons
The four-time Emmy Award-winning musical competition series "The Voice" returns with the strongest vocalists from across the country invited to compete in the show's newest season.
61   Metascore
2011 Game Show, Music, Reality

Naked and Afraid

19 Seasons
Stripped down and stranded, Naked and Afraid veterans return for the most isolating challenge yet. With no tribe, partner or help of any kind, mental toughness plays a key role in making it through this 21-day survival challenge alone.
62   Metascore
2013 Action & Adventure, Game Show, Horror, Reality

1000-lb Sisters

8 Seasons
The Slaton's are larger-than-life sisters who have always relied on each other and food for support. Amy, age 31, is desperate to have children, but hasn't been able to due to her weight. While Tammy, age 32, is one step away from being bedridden.
2020 Reality

The Masked Singer

14 Seasons
The Masked Singer is a singing competition guessing game based on the Korean format King of Mask Singer. The performers are celebrities wearing elaborate head to toe costumes to conceal their identities from the host, panelists, audience, and other contestants. 12 celebrities appear on the show with one singer eliminated each week and unmasked. Small hints are given to help viewer play and guess along. The "who-sung-it" is hosted by Nick Cannon and features a star-studded detective playing panel: Ken Jeong, Jenny McCarthy, Nicole Scherzinger and Robin Thicke. For season 1, the competitors are all "household names" and have a combined 65 Grammy nominations, 16 multi-Platinum albums, 16 Emmy nominations, 9 Broadway shows, 4 Super Bowl titles, and 4 stars on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.
36   Metascore
2019 Family, Music, Reality